Maximize
Your Exclusion of Foreign Earned Income Under the Physical Presence Test
If your tax home is in a foreign country, in order to exclude all or
some of your foreign earned income, you must meet either the bona fide
residence test or the physical presence test. Of course, your tax
home
is your regular or principal place of business or employment.
Generally, if you are a bona fide resident of a foreign country for an
uninterrupted period (excluding brief or temporary trips for vacation
or business) that includes an entire tax year, then you meet the bona
fide residence test. Once you have met this test, then you are a
bona
fide resident of that country for all years of residence there,
including partial years. For instance, if you arrived in the foreign
country in the middle of year 1, remained for the entire year 2, and
then left in the middle of year 3, then you were a bona fide resident
of the foreign country for all of year 2, and half of years 1 and 3.
The problem with meeting the bona fide residence test is that your
arrival rarely, if ever, would occur just prior to January 1st,
qualifying you for an entire tax year in your first year of residence
in the foreign country. Consequently, in order to exclude your
first
year’s foreign earned income, the physical presence test is customarily
used in the first year of residence in a foreign country in order to
qualify for exclusion of foreign earned income.
Generally, to meet the physical presence test, you must be physically
present in the foreign country for at least 330 full days during a
12-month period. For example, if you were physically present in
the
foreign country from April 15 2009 through April 15, 2011, and you
wished to file a tax return for the year 2009 on April 15, 2010,
excluding your foreign earned income, you would be able to do so under
the physical presence test; however, you would not be able to do so
under the bona fide residence test because you were not a bona fide
resident of the foreign country for the entire tax year beginning
January 1, 2009 and ending December 31, 2009.
The question is—and the purpose of this article—is how would you
maximize the exclusion of foreign earned income under the physical
presence test. For instance, assuming you did not leave the
foreign
country at all during 2009, would you simply multiply the maximum
annual exclusion limit of foreign earned income for the year
2009—$91,400—by 261/365 (261/365 representing the “annual rate” of
Section 911(b)(2)(A), where 261 is the number of days from April 15th
through December 31st and, of course, 365 is the total number of days
in the year 2009)? If you do such, then the maximum amount of
foreign
earned income that you could exclude from tax would be $65,357.
Is
there a way of applying the physical presence test to increase the
exclusion of foreign earned income from tax than simply by using the
first full day after your arrival date in the foreign country to
compute the “annual rate”?
Yes, there is; otherwise, why would I bother to write this article in
the first place? For the year of arrival, you would compute the
maximum exclusion as follows:
- Count forward 330 days from your first day of
physical residence, excluding any vacation and business days in the
United States;
- Count backward 12 months from the date determined in
step 1 above;
- Count the total days from the date determined in step
2 above through the end of the tax year;
- Multiply the maximum exclusion limit for the
applicable tax year
by the annual rate, or the number of days determined in step 3 above by
the total calendar days in the tax year (either 365 or 366).
If April 15, 2009 were the first full day of residence in the foreign
country, the 330th day forward would be March 10, 2010, which would be
the last day of the 12 consecutive month period relevant to the tax
year 2009. Counting backward 12 months from that date provides
the
first date of our exclusion period for 2009: March 11,
2009. Counting
the total days from March 11, 2009 through December 31, 2009, gives us
297 days for the numerator in our annual rate formula used to compute
the maximum allowable exclusion of foreign earned income: 297/365
x
$91,400, or $74,372 of maximum excludible foreign earned income.
All other things being equal, and assuming you were single and your
foreign earned income exceeded $74,372, by using these four steps to
derive the numerator in your annual rate fraction for the computation
of your foreign earned income exclusion—rather than simply using your
arrival date to derive the numerator in your the annual rate
fraction—you would have saved $2,250 in federal income taxes and $451
in Connecticut income taxes.
Now let’s consider your year of departure. As in the year of
arrival,
if you were simply to include the number of days you were in the
foreign country in that tax year in the numerator of your annual rate
for the year 2011, the amount of foreign income eligible for exclusion
would be the following, assuming a maximum exclusion of $91,500 for
2011: 105/365 x $91,500 = $26,322.
To maximize your exclusion of foreign earned income in your year of
departure, you would figure the maximum exclusion in a manner similar
to that used in figuring your maximum exclusion in your year of
arrival, except in the opposite direction:
- Count backward 330 days from your last day of
physical residence, excluding any vacation and business days in the
United States;
- Count forward 12 months from the date determined in
step 1 above;
- Count the total days in your year of departure from
January 1 through the date determined in step 2;
- Multiply the maximum exclusion limit for the
applicable tax year
by the annual rate, or the number of days determined in step 3 above by
the total calendar days in the tax year (either 365 or 366).
If April 15, 2011 were the last full day of residence in the foreign
country, the 330th day backward would be May 21, 2010, which would be
the first day of the 12 consecutive month period relevant to the tax
year 2011. Counting forward 12 months from that date provides the
last
date of our exclusion period for 2011: May 20, 2011.
Counting the
total days from January 1, 2011 through May 20, 2011, gives us 140 days
for the numerator in our annual rate formula used to compute the
maximum allowable exclusion of foreign earned income: 140/365 x
$91,500, or $35,096 of maximum excludible foreign earned income.
Once again, all other things being equal, and assuming you were single
and your foreign earned income exceeded $35,096, by using these four
steps to derive the numerator in your annual rate fraction for the
computation of your foreign earned income exclusion—rather than simply
using your departure date to derive the numerator in your the annual
rate fraction—you would have saved $1,425 in federal income taxes and
$439 in Connecticut income taxes.
All in all, all other things being equal, and assuming you were single
and your foreign earned income exceeded the calculated excludible
amounts, by using the respective four steps to derive the number of
days you are physically present in your years of arrival and departure
instead of simply basing their derivations on the dates of arrival and
departure results in this specific example in federal income tax
savings of $3,675 and Connecticut income tax savings of $890, or total
income tax savings of $4,565. Of course, different savings in
income
taxes would result in different circumstances; however, the employment
of the above-mentioned methodologies would ensure the maximum exclusion
of foreign earned income and maximum tax savings.
The obvious question is, why are you allowed to include days prior to
your arrival and subsequent to your departure in the numerator of your
annual rate factor? There are several reasons. First, you
are required to be in the foreign country 330 days, not 365 days.
Secondly, you are allowed to choose any 12 consecutive months of your
required year of residency, whether or not that year pre-dates or
post-dates your dates of arrival and departure, respectively.
Thirdly, your period of physical residence for the purpose of computing
your annual rate is not strictly limited by arrival or departure
dates. As a result, by using these four-step procedures in
determining the beginning and ending dates of your physical presence in
the foreign country, you can add as much as 35 or 36 days to the
numerator in your annual rate fraction, or 10% of the maximum annual
exclusion limit. Since taxpayers claiming the foreign earned
income exclusion are taxed at the much higher marginal tax rates that
would have applied had they not claimed the exclusion, the tax
consequences of not maximizing one's exclusion can be significant.
This article is provided for informational purposes and is
not intended to be construed as legal, accounting, or other
professional advice. For further information, please consult
appropriate professional advice from your attorney and certified public
accountant.
Have a tax, a QuickBooks, or an accounting question? Please feel free to submit
it under "Comments" on our blog, Accounting, QuickBooks, and Taxes by
William Brighenti,
Certified Public
Accountant, Accountants CPA Hartford, LLC. For information
and assistance on
any tax, QuickBooks, or accounting issue, please visit our website: Accountants CPA
Hartford, LLC.
If and only
to the extent that this publication contains contributions from tax
professionals who are subject to the
rules of professional conduct set forth in Circular 230, as promulgated
by the United States Department of the Treasury, the publisher, on
behalf of those
contributors, hereby states that any U.S. federal tax advice that is
contained in such contributions was not intended or written to be used
by any taxpayer for the purpose of avoiding penalties that may be
imposed on the
taxpayer by the Internal Revenue Service, and it cannot be used by any
taxpayer for
such purpose. The above tax advice was
written to support the promotion or marketing of the accounting
practice of the publisher and any transaction described herein. The taxpayer recipients of this offering
memorandum should seek tax advice based on their particular
circumstances from an independent
tax advisor.
|